A Juicy Lucy is a burger filled with cheese, so the cheese melts inside the meat patty as an alternative of sitting on prime. This Juicy Lucy recipe isn’t simply any burger, although. It’s a flavor-packed throwback to my childhood. My dad used to name these his “connoisseur burgers,” and as a child, that sizzling, tacky heart made them really feel additional particular. However little did I do know, they’re extremely straightforward to make and tremendous budget-friendly! With simply floor beef, just a few pantry seasonings, and good ol’ American cheese, you may recreate that very same juicy, stuffed burger magic at residence with none fancy instruments or substances. I prepare dinner mine in a skillet, however they’re nice on the grill, too!
Pin this recipe for later!
All recipes are rigorously examined in our Nashville Check Kitchen to make sure they’re straightforward, reasonably priced, and scrumptious.
Juicy Cheese Stuffed Burgers
A Juicy Lucy (generally spelled Jucy Lucy) is a cheese-stuffed burger that originated in Minnesota, particularly in Minneapolis. Each Matt’s Bar and the 5-8 Membership famously declare to have created it, and actually, I get why persons are so keen about it. It’s mainly an inside-out cheeseburger, with the cheese sealed inside the meat as an alternative of layered on prime like a traditional burger. Because it cooks, the cheese melts right into a sizzling, gooey heart that spills out whenever you take a chunk. 🤤
For me, a Juicy Lucy is barely ever made with American cheese. That’s how I’ve all the time recognized it, and it actually does soften the perfect for this type of burger. The skinny slices fold neatly into the middle, soften rapidly, and switch creamy and molten with out getting stringy. As for the meat, I maintain it easy with Worcestershire sauce, garlic powder, salt, and pepper so the flavour stays traditional and beefy. Then I flatten the meat into skinny patties, tuck the cheese within the center, and pinch the sides closed so the melty cheese stays the place it belongs. It’s a straightforward, budget-friendly solution to make a burger really feel additional particular, and the primary chunk is pure tacky nostalgia.
- Don’t overwork the meat. I combine the bottom beef and seasonings simply till mixed as a result of the extra you mash and squeeze the meat, the tighter it packs collectively, which might make the burgers dense as an alternative of juicy and tender.
- Make the patties skinny and seal them effectively. Every burger makes use of two skinny patties, and I wish to make them slightly wider than the bun, as they’ll shrink barely as they prepare dinner. Additionally, make certain to go away a border across the cheese, then pinch and clean the sides so the cheese stays tucked inside. Don’t stress if slightly cheese spills out as they prepare dinner (you may see mine did within the photographs beneath, however they nonetheless turned out tremendous tacky!).
- Don’t press the burgers whereas they prepare dinner. Urgent down can squeeze out the juices and break the seal, which is the quickest solution to lose that melty cheese heart.
- Allow them to relaxation earlier than serving. Resting offers the juices time to settle, and the cheese time to thicken barely, so the primary chunk is gooey and melty as an alternative of dangerously sizzling and runny.
- Maintain the toppings traditional or gown them up. Pickles are my go-to for a easy, traditional Juicy Lucy chunk, however grilled onions, lettuce, tomato, mustard, ketchup, burger sauce, or comeback sauce are all scrumptious right here.
Juicy Lucy (Cheese Stuffed Burgers)
Value $8.57 recipe / $2.14 serving
These straightforward Juicy Lucy cheese stuffed burgers are full of melty American cheese, easy seasonings, and massive diner-style taste on a funds!
-
Collect all substances.
-
In a big bowl mix the bottom beef with the Worcestershire sauce, garlic powder, salt, and pepper.
-
Divide the bottom beef combination into 8 equal parts; they need to be about 3 oz. every. Type into balls.
-
Place parchment paper or plastic wrap over every ball of beef and flatten out with backside of heavy skillet to kind 8 skinny patties.***
-
Lay 4 slices of American cheese in a fan form within the heart of 1 patty, leaving a little bit of house across the edges. Prime with a second patty and pinch the sides to seal, ensuring the cheese stays inside.
-
Warmth oil in a medium iron skillet over medium warmth. As soon as oil is sizzling and shimmering, place patties within the skillet, taking care to not transfer for 3 minutes.
-
Flip and prepare dinner for an additional 3 minutes on the opposite facet****.
-
Switch the burgers to a plate and allow them to relaxation for five minutes. Whereas they relaxation, toast your buns in the identical skillet.
-
Serve the juicy lucy burgers with dill pickle slices and your favourite toppings and sauces. Take pleasure in!
See how we calculate recipe prices right here.
**If American cheese isn’t your factor, you may swap in slices of cheddar as an alternative. Simply be aware the prepare dinner time might range, and the cheese might not soften in addition to American cheese. Additionally don’t add additional cheese, tempting as it’s, as a result of overstuffed patties usually tend to cut up and leak!
***I exploit an iron skillet to flatten out my burgers however be happy to make use of a burger press you probably have one.
****In case you desire your burger extra effectively achieved, prepare dinner it for an additional 1-2 minutes per facet. Floor beef ought to attain 160°F as soon as cooked, however as a result of the middle is full of cheese, the temperature could be tough to verify. Search for burgers which can be deeply browned, agency across the edges, and now not pink on the seams.
Grill instructions: Preheat your grill to medium-high warmth and frivolously oil the grates. Place the stuffed patties on the grill and prepare dinner for 3–5 minutes per facet, or till the burgers are browned with grill marks and the cheese is melted within the heart. Don’t press down on the patties as they prepare dinner, or the cheese might leak out. Switch the stuffed burgers to a plate and allow them to relaxation for five minutes. Toast the buns on the grill and serve with pickles and your favourite toppings.
Serving: 1juicy lucyEnergy: 702kcal (35%)Carbohydrates: 23g (8%)Protein: 39g (78%)Fats: 49g (75%)Sodium: 1473mg (64%)Fiber: 1g (4%)
how you can make Juicy Lucy Burgers Step-by-Step Photographs
Collect all your substances.
Season the meat: Add 1½ lbs floor beef to a big bowl with 1 tsp Worcestershire sauce, 1 tsp garlic powder, 1 tsp salt, and ½ tsp freshly cracked black pepper. Use your fingers or a fork to softly combine every little thing collectively simply till mixed. Strive to not overwork the meat, or the burgers can end up dense as an alternative of juicy.
Type the patties: Now evenly divide the meat combination into 8 equal parts (about 3 oz. every), and roll every portion right into a ball.
Place one beef ball between two items of parchment paper or plastic wrap. Press it down with the underside of a heavy skillet or a burger press till it types a skinny, even patty. Repeat with the remaining beef balls till you could have 8 skinny patties. The patties needs to be vast sufficient to carry the cheese within the heart with slightly room across the edges for sealing.
Stuff with cheese: Place 6 quarters of American cheese within the heart of 1 patty, barely overlapping them in a small stack or fan form. Depart a border across the edge so you may seal the patties correctly. Prime with a second patty, then firmly pinch and press the sides collectively all the way in which round to lure the cheese inside.
Clean any cracks or skinny spots along with your fingers so the cheese is much less more likely to leak out whereas cooking. Repeat till you could have 4 stuffed burgers.
Cook dinner the burgers: Warmth 1 Tbsp cooking oil in a medium forged iron skillet over medium warmth. As soon as the oil is sizzling and shimmering, fastidiously add the stuffed burgers to the skillet. Cook dinner with out shifting them for about 3 minutes, or till the bottoms are deeply browned and the sides begin to look cooked.
Flip the burgers and prepare dinner for an additional 3 minutes on the opposite facet. For a extra well-done burger, prepare dinner for an additional 1-2 minutes per facet.
As soon as cooked, switch the burgers to a plate and allow them to relaxation for five minutes. The cheese inside will likely be very popular, so this quick relaxation helps the juices settle and retains the primary chunk from being molten!
Toast the buns: Whereas the patties relaxation, place the 4 hamburger buns cut-side down in the identical skillet (fastidiously wipe away any melted cheese, if desired!) and toast them for a minute or two, simply till golden and frivolously crisp across the edges.
Serve the stuffed Juicy Lucy burgers on the toasted buns with 3 pickle slices every. You too can add any additional toppings or sauces you want (non-compulsory). Take pleasure in whereas the cheese remains to be sizzling and melty!
Serving Ideas
These Juicy Lucy burgers are wealthy, tacky, and tremendous savory, so I like pairing them with one thing cool, crunchy, or slightly candy on the facet. Creamy coleslaw is a traditional selection as a result of the tangy dressing and crisp cabbage steadiness out all that melty cheese. For a full cookout-style plate, you may’t go flawed with Southern-style potato salad or macaroni salad. Each are chilly sides you may make forward, which is all the time a win when these burgers are concerned. And if you would like one thing slightly totally different from common fries, our spicy candy potato fries are good right here. The candy, salty, and spicy taste works completely with the beefy stuffed burgers and gooey American cheese heart.
Juicy Lucy burgers are greatest freshly made, when the cheese is melty, the meat is juicy, and the buns are heat and toasty. But when I’m planning forward, I’d a lot moderately prep the stuffed patties upfront than reheat leftovers later. Form and stuff the burgers, place them on a parchment-lined plate or baking sheet, cowl, and refrigerate for as much as 24 hours. Since they’ll be chilly, give them 1-2 minutes additional within the skillet so the meat cooks via and the cheese will get good and gooey within the center.
Storage and Reheating
Retailer any leftover patties in an hermetic container within the fridge for 3-4 days. Maintain the stuffed burgers and buns separate if potential so the bread doesn’t get smooth. This recipe is straightforward to scale up or down, so I like to recommend solely cooking what you intend to eat recent in case you can!
Reheating
Reheat the patties in a skillet over medium-low warmth till the meat is warmed via and the cheese melts once more within the heart. You too can use the microwave in brief bursts.
Freezing
Wrap the cooked and cooled patties tightly and retailer them in a freezer-safe bag or container for as much as 3 months. Thaw them within the fridge in a single day earlier than reheating to assist the cheese soften evenly within the heart with out overcooking the meat across the edges.
