Witch Finger Cookies- Actually Terrifying Treats For Halloween

Jersey Farm Scribe right here and I completely LOVE Halloween. There’s something a few day we rejoice by attempting to frighten ourselves that excites me and feeds into my playful mischievous facet. So it’s becoming that lower than per week earlier than Halloween marks my début put up for Household Focus Weblog. I’m honored to be within the firm of such creativity and professionalism and I hope you get pleasure from my Witch Finger Halloween Cookies recipe!  Convey these Halloween cookies to any get together and I assure you’ll get an eye-popping response from mini ghosts and grown-up goblins alike. However I warn you, relying on how they’re carried out, these can look really terrifying. They’ll invoke fairly the response from little ones and the blood might even be thought-about too “gory” for a faculty class get together.  What can I say? Proceed at your individual threat! Printable recipe card on the backside of the put up.

Spooky Witch Finger Cookies Recipe

Making Witch Finger Cookies is a enjoyable and festive method to rejoice Halloween! These spooky treats are formed like creepy fingers with almond “nails” and crimson “blood” icing or jam, making them a success at events and with youngsters. They’re not solely scrumptious—normally buttery shortbread or sugar cookies—but in addition spark creativity and laughter whereas baking. Plus, they’re an ideal hands-on exercise for youths to assist with, from shaping the dough to including the eerie particulars. In brief, Witch Finger Cookies mix Halloween enjoyable, creativity, and attractive selfmade goodness multi functional spooky snack!

Halloween Cookies Substances:

• 1 1/2 cup sliced almonds (purchase these within the baking part, not with the snacking nuts and also you’ll get monetary savings!)
• 6 oz (3/4 of an 8oz package deal) cream cheese
• ½ cup butter (1 stick)
• ¾ cup powdered sugar
• ¼ cup common white sugar
• 1 tsp almond extract (or vanilla is okay)
• 1 egg yolk
• ¼ tsp salt
• 2 cup flour
• Pink cake adorning gel or icing
• Mini chocolate chips

Recipe Prep:

Preheat oven to 350 levels F and line baking sheets with parchment paper. (Not 100% mandatory, you may simply spray with Pam or paint with oil, however I desire parchment paper for cookies.)

How To Make Witch Finger Cookies:

Witch finger cookies are a enjoyable and eerie Halloween deal with that appear to be spooky witch fingers. Right here’s a easy recipe to make these scrumptious and creepy cookies:

The first step: Almonds

Pour the almonds out on counter and discover 40 or so that will make good fingernails and put them apart. Put the remaining within the meals processor. Course of. Loads. You possibly can’t actually over course of right here.

You’re in search of tiny, positive items.

Step two: Remainder of substances

Take the cream cheese and butter and put in bowl, and break into items. IF IT’S A GLASS BOWL, however the entire thing within the microwave for about 40 seconds or so to melt. Mush up. Again in microwave for 15-20 seconds.

Toss in the remainder of the substances (reserving a few half cup of flour). Don’t fear in regards to the precise order. (Some people GASP at my lack of order, or mixing in-between however so long as you maintain off on a little bit of flour, I feel you’re lined.) Beat with a mixer.

Then add the remainder of the flour and blend it round with a fork. You’re in search of a dough you may roll between your fingers and form a bit, however remains to be be comfortable to the contact. If you have to, add as much as one other ¼ cup of flour or so.

Step three: Shaping

Roll the dough between your fingers into little logs. It’ll be a comfortable dough, so be mild. You possibly can type them additional on the parchment paper anyway. At first you simply need a fundamental log. Use your fingers to make lumpy spots for knuckles and skinny spots in-between. Use a pointy knife to make indents on the knuckles. Then put crimson adorning gel icing on the tip. Don’t be neat! Blood is messy!

Step 4: Adorning

You too can drizzle a couple of spots of blood throughout the finger for extra blood.  Then put an enormous dollop on the very tip, and push an almond sliver fingernail into the dollop of icing.  Don’t middle it.  Bloody fingers are hardly ever symmetrical.  Simply stick it on there and let the goo ooze out the place it could!  And you may stick a “wart” (mini chocolate chip) or two wherever you see match.

Pop these within the 350 for 13-16 minutes or till you begin to see them browning on the underside. Time will depend on measurement of the cookies. I feel thinner fingers are scarier. My skinny ones are solely in regards to the width of a pencil once they go within the oven. The dough is specifically made so it received’t unfold out TOO a lot, however they do get a bit bulkier as they cook dinner.

This image exhibits the distinction between witch finger dough that was in regards to the width of a finger when it went within the oven (proper) versus dough the width of a pencil:

Each spooky and yummy, so don’t stress the dimensions an excessive amount of!

How To Make An Straightforward Halloween Sugar Cookies Model Of Witch Fingers

Searching for a CHEAT????!!!! Wish to save time?

Simply use sugar cookie dough. It can unfold out extra, will likely be a bit flat and received’t have fairly the identical coloring, however you may type ANY dough into scary fingers. And the youngsters will nonetheless assume you’re a Halloween Hero!  

I made the 2 above with common cookie dough I had within the fridge. Not fairly as reasonable, however nonetheless an enormous hit with Halloween cookie eaters and Fright Fest go-ers alike!

Irrespective of the way you do them, these Halloween cookies are positive to shock your visitors and showcase the final word Halloween expertise to all of your senses.   They’ll deliver concern to your eyes, shrieks of pleasure and terror to your ears all whereas delighting your style buds.

Printable Halloween Cookies Recipe For Witch Fingers

Witch Finger Cookies- Actually Terrifying Treats For Halloween

These spooky almond flavored Witch Finger Cookies are excellent for Halloween events and enjoyable to make!

12345

Price this recipe

|

Substances

• 1 1/2 cups sliced almonds
• 6 oz cream cheese, sliced into 6 items
• ½ cup butter, sliced into 8 items
• ¾ cup powdered sugar
• ¼ cup granulated sugar
• 1 tsp almond extract
• 1 egg yolk
• ¼ tsp salt
• 2 cups all goal flour
• Pink cake adorning gel
• 1/8 cup mini chocolate chips

Directions

1. Preheat oven to 350 levels and line a cookie sheet with parchment paper.
2. Pour the almonds out on counter and discover 40 that may make good fingernails and put them apart. Put the remaining within the meals processor and grind till positive.
3. In a big microwave protected bowl, add the cream cheese and butter. Put the entire thing within the microwave for about 40 seconds or so to melt. Combine gently and place again in microwave for one more 15-20 seconds.
4. Add the powered sugar, granulated sugar, extract, and egg yolk. Combine till blended. Add the flour and salt (reserving a few half cup of flour for later).
5. Combine till blended.
6. Add the remainder of the flour and blend it till simply blended. You’re in search of a dough you may roll between your fingers and form a bit, however remains to be be comfortable to the contact. If you have to, add as much as one other ¼ cup of flour to realize this consistency.
7. Roll the dough between your fingers into little logs. Then, use your fingers to make lumpy spots for knuckles and skinny spots in-between. Place on parchment paper.
8. Use a pointy knife to make indents on the knuckles.
9. Put crimson gel icing on the tip of fingers the place they’d be hooked up to a hand.
10. Then put an enormous dollop of crimson gel on the finger tip and push an almond sliver fingernail into the dollop of gel.
11. Lastly, you may stick a “wart” (mini chocolate chip) or two or three wherever you see match.
12. Pop the tray within the 350 preheated over for 13-16 minutes or till you begin to see them browning.
13. Take away from oven and permit to chill.
14. Serve and revel in!

Vitamin Details

Witch Finger Cookies- Actually Terrifying Treats For Halloween

Serves: 20

Quantity Per Serving: 2 cookies
Energy		192.21 kcal
% Every day Worth*
Complete Fats 11.59 g		16.9%
	Saturated Fats 5.1 g	25%
	Trans Fats 0.19 g
Ldl cholesterol 29.07 mg		9.7%
Sodium 62.46 mg		2.6%
Complete Carbohydrate 19.37 g		6.3%
	Dietary Fiber 1.24 g	4%
	Sugars 8.41 g
Protein 3.48 g

Vitamin A 8.06 %		Vitamin C 0.01 %
Calcium 3.27 %		Iron 5.05 %

* % Every day Values are primarily based on a 2,000 calorie weight loss plan. Your each day values could also be larger or decrease relying in your calorie wants.

Household Focus Weblog

© 2025 Copyright Household Focus Weblog

Do you assume you’ll make these Halloween cookies? Get pleasure from serving these witch finger cookies at your Halloween get together or as a spooky deal with for household and mates! Will be capable to eat the witch fingers cookies? LOL. I’d love to listen to your ideas and methods for the fantastic world of werewolves, monsters and different creatures of the evening. Attain out on social media @familyfocusblog

Associated Submit:

5 Finest Halloween Deal with Recipes

Jello Worms

Straightforward Selfmade Halloween Costumes