For me, the one factor that’s extra nostalgic “New York” than watching the ball drop in Occasions Sq. on New 12 months’s Eve are these Black and White Cookies! They’re pillowy and candy like a slice of cake however straightforward to eat by hand like a cookie, adorned half and half with vanilla and chocolate icing. These cookies are the right marriage of two of the perfect sweets of ALL TIME! They had been my favourite afternoon deal with once I lived in New York in my early 20s, and so they all the time ship me on a visit again down reminiscence lane. And since this recipe is so straightforward to make at dwelling, I can carry a little bit style of NYC into my kitchen anytime I would like!
This publish incorporates some affiliate hyperlinks, which signifies that we make a small fee off gadgets you buy at no extra value to you.
Once I consider black and white cookies, I consider my time interning with a giant, fancy leisure PR agency in New York Metropolis roughly 1,000 years in the past. My internship within the Large Apple predates my curiosity in ever changing into an expert chef, however it’s nonetheless a giant a part of my private historical past that obtained me right here! Why? It’s my opinion that New York Metropolis is perhaps essentially the most thrilling metropolis within the nation with regards to FOOD. You possibly can simply make a journey around the globe in in the future by consuming your manner via the town. I’m extra of a rustic mouse, so I used to be blissful to maneuver to Nashville on the finish of my internship, however the flavors and hustle and bustle will all the time be a fond reminiscence of mine.
Do you’ve got any memorable culinary experiences whereas visiting or residing in New York Metropolis? Share them along with your assessment!
What are Black and White Cookies?
Black and white cookies are a basic New York Metropolis bakery deal with. They’re tender, cake-like cookies topped with vanilla and chocolate icing, giving them their iconic black-and-white look. The icing itself has a slight lemon taste and hardens because it dries. While you chunk into it, the icing crackles, creating the most satisfying texture together with the candy, buttery taste of the cakey cookie base!
These cookies date manner again to the early twentieth century, with Glaser’s Bake Store typically credited because the originator. Over time, they’ve additionally turn out to be a staple in Jewish bakeries, and there’s a variation discovered throughout Germany referred to as “Amerikaner.” Black and white cookies are additionally sometimes called a “half moon cookie,” which (relying on who you ask!) are technically one other kind of cookie intently related to NYC, that includes a barely completely different texture and a tender frosting.
Right here’s what you’ll have to make these straightforward black and white cookies:
- All-Goal Flour: The bottom of the cookie dough batter. You’ll want to sift it BEFORE measuring out the quantity specified within the recipe—extra on this beneath!
- Milk & Distilled White Vinegar: I combine these substances collectively to make do-it-yourself buttermilk. This provides a little bit tang to the batter and likewise helps with the rise because it reacts with the baking soda. Making buttermilk this manner additionally prevents you from having to buy a complete carton that you could be not use!
- Baking Soda: Creates the right rise for making the cake-like texture these cookies are well-known for.
- Eggs: I take advantage of two massive eggs because the binder to carry every thing collectively.
- Unsalted Butter: I want unsalted butter so I can higher management the quantity of salt on this recipe. You’ll want to soften your butter first and let it cool so it doesn’t prepare dinner the eggs when added to the batter.
- Granulated Sugar: Provides moisture and sweetness, in fact!
- Vanilla Extract: Flavors the tender cookie base and the icing with a heat vanilla taste.
- Salt: Only a pinch to stability out the sweetness.
- Unsweetened Cocoa Powder: Use unsweetened cocoa powder to make the chocolate icing half.
- Powdered Sugar: That is also called confectioners sugar or icing sugar and is used to make the icing! I like to recommend sifting it earlier than utilizing it to keep away from lumps.
- Mild Corn Syrup: Helps to thicken the icing and provides a pleasant shine. You’ll want to use gentle corn syrup, not darkish. Darkish corn syrup will change the colour and taste of the icing.
- Sizzling Water & Lemon Juice: These liquids combine with the powdered sugar to create the white glaze icing. I take advantage of scorching water as a result of it dissolves the sugar extra simply and makes it a lot simpler to combine with the thick corn syrup. The lemon juice additionally provides a delicate lemon taste, which helps these do-it-yourself black and white cookies style identical to the true factor!
What’s the Distinction Between Frosting and Icing?
This recipe makes use of an icing, not a frosting. Icing is usually thinner and glossier and is used as a glaze on high of baked items. It additionally often hardens because it dries, making it good for making a easy end. Our sugar cookies are one other instance of a recipe made with icing fairly than frosting! Then again, frosting is thicker and creamier, like what I take advantage of in my eggnog cookies or in our strawberry sheet cake recipe. It may be unfold or piped and stays tender and fluffy. Each are scrumptious, however for these cookies, I need a easy, shiny end (identical to an actual NYC black and white cookie!), so icing is the one solution to go.
Once I first tried to recreate these cookies at dwelling, I knew getting the cookie base was crucial half. It HAD to be good—tender, cakey, and durable sufficient to carry the icing. To attain this texture, I take advantage of two issues: buttermilk and SIFTED flour!
You should sift your flour earlier than measuring out the 1.5 cups used on this recipe. This removes any lumps and aerates the flour, making it lighter (making a softer cookie) and likewise stops you from by accident packing an excessive amount of flour into your measuring cup. And the do-it-yourself buttermilk prompts the baking powder, giving the cookies a slight raise and serving to them to remain tender and tender. Each are important steps and make an enormous distinction—belief me!
Recipe Suggestions!
- Let your melted butter cool earlier than mixing it into the cookie dough batter. I take advantage of melted butter to maintain the cookies tender with a barely chewier texture, but when it’s too scorching whenever you combine it in, it would by accident prepare dinner your eggs!
- Combine the dry and moist substances individually earlier than slowly combining. This stops you from overmixing the dough, which may make the cookies dense and difficult fairly than tender and pillowy.
- Double-check that your baking soda isn’t expired! When you’ve had it for some time, I extremely advocate checking the expiration date in your baking soda. Expired baking soda gained’t give the identical rise, and I don’t need that to destroy your do-it-yourself treats! You can too take a look at the activeness of your baking soda by including it to a small quantity of vinegar—if it fizzes, it’s nonetheless good.
- Embellish the flat aspect of the cookies. As soon as they’re totally cooled, flip the cookies over so the underside is going through up. This offers you a easy floor to brighten with the chocolate and vanilla icing. If you need the colours to turn out to be extra opaque and outlined, I like to recommend letting the primary layer of icing dry earlier than including extra.
Storage Directions
I like these cookies finest throughout the first 24 hours of baking whereas they’re nonetheless tremendous tender and contemporary. Nonetheless, they are often saved in an hermetic container at room temperature for as much as 3-4 days. You can too freeze them, with out the icing, for as much as 3 months and thaw at room temperature earlier than adorning and serving!
Black and White Cookies Recipe
These do-it-yourself Black and White Cookies are tender, candy, and topped with half vanilla and half chocolate icing—identical to those you will discover in New York!
Forestall your display from going darkish
Cookie Components
- ⅓ cup milk ($0.09)
- 1 tsp distilled white vinegar ($0.01)
- 1 ½ cups flour, sifted ($0.24)
- ¼ tsp salt ($0.01)
- ½ tsp baking soda ($0.01)
- 7 Tbsp unsalted butter, melted and cooled ($0.91)
- ¾ cup granulated sugar ($0.29)
- 2 massive eggs ($0.66)
- 1 tsp vanilla extract ($0.64)
Icing Components
- 2 ¼ cups powdered sugar, sifted ($0.99)
- 1 tsp lemon juice ($0.01)
- 1 Tbsp scorching water ($0.00)
- ½ tsp vanilla extract ($0.32)
- 2 Tbsp gentle corn syrup ($0.14)
- 2 tsp unsweetened cocoa powder ($0.12)
-
Preheat oven to 350°F and mix milk and vinegar collectively to make buttermilk. Put aside. Then, sift flour in a mesh strainer (or a sifter when you’ve got one) over a big mixing bowl. Measure out 1 ½ cups of sifted flour.
-
Mix sifted flour, salt and baking soda in a mixing bowl, whisking to mix.
-
Pour melted-but-cooled butter to a big mixing bowl with sugar. Combine with a hand mixer on low to mix.
-
Then, beat eggs and vanilla collectively and add it to the sugar butter combination.
-
Add a few of the sifted flour combination to the moist combination and blend on medium pace.
-
Then, alternating with the flour combination, add buttermilk. Do that forwards and backwards till the flour combination and buttermilk have each been used up and are utterly mixed.
-
Cool the batter for half-hour to at least one hour within the fridge.
-
Utilizing a 1 oz cookie scoop, scoop cookie dough onto parchment-lined baking sheets, giving the cookies at the very least 2 inches of area between them.
-
Bake for quarter-hour till the sides are simply barely golden. Allow them to cool utterly when you put together the icing!
-
Sift powdered sugar to eliminate any lumps.
-
Mix the powdered sugar, lemon juice, scorching water, vanilla extract and light-weight corn syrup, stirring to mix. Equally divide the icing into 2 small bowls.
-
To the second bowl, add the cocoa powder, stirring till easy.
-
As soon as your cookies have utterly cooled after baking, frost the flat aspect of every cookie (sure, the aspect that was down on the baking sheet!) rigorously with a butter knife or elevated spatula. It’s possible you’ll have to ice them a pair instances to tidy up the traces and have 2 colours that stand out.
-
Nonetheless, don’t be concerned if the colours run into one another; your cookies will nonetheless style scrumptious! Allow them to dry utterly on a wire rack earlier than serving.
See how we calculate recipe prices right here.
-
Mesh Sieve
-
Hand Mixer
-
Wire Cooling Racks
Serving: 1cookie (made with a 1 oz scoop)Energy: 112kcalCarbohydrates: 20gProtein: 1gFats: 3gSodium: 45mgFiber: 0.2g
Learn our full vitamin disclaimer right here.
how one can make Black and White Cookies – step-by-step pictures
Preheat oven to 350F and mix ⅓ cup milk and 1 tsp distilled white vinegar collectively to make buttermilk. Put aside. Then, sift flour in a mesh strainer (or a sifter when you’ve got one) over a big mixing bowl. Measure out 1 ½ cups of sifted flour.
Mix sifted flour, ¼ tsp salt, and ½ tsp baking soda in a mixing bowl, whisking to mix.
Pour 7 Tbsp of melted-but-cooled butter to a big mixing bowl with ¾ cup granulated sugar. Combine with a hand mixer on low to mix.
Then, beat 2 massive eggs and 1 tsp vanilla extract collectively and add it to the sugar butter combination.
Add a few of the sifted flour combination to the moist combination and blend on medium pace.
Then, alternating with the flour combination, add buttermilk. Do that forwards and backwards till the flour combination and buttermilk have each been used up and are utterly mixed.
Cool the batter for half-hour to at least one hour within the fridge.
Utilizing a 1 oz cookie scoop, scoop cookie dough onto parchment-lined baking sheets, giving the cookies at the very least 2 inches of area between them.
Bake for quarter-hour till the sides are simply barely golden. Allow them to cool utterly when you put together the icing!
Sift 2 ¼ cups powdered sugar to eliminate any lumps.
Mix the powdered sugar, 1 tsp lemon juice, 1 Tbsp scorching water, ½ tsp vanilla extract, and a pair of Tbsp gentle corn syrup, stirring to mix. Equally divide the icing into 2 small bowls.
Within the second bowl, add 2 tsp cocoa powder, stirring till easy.
As soon as your cookies have utterly cooled after baking, frost the flat aspect of every cookie (sure, the aspect that was down on the baking sheet!) rigorously with a butter knife or elevated spatula.
It’s possible you’ll have to ice them a pair instances to tidy up the traces and have 2 colours that stand out.
Nonetheless, don’t fear if the colours run into one another; your cookies will nonetheless style scrumptious! Allow them to dry utterly on a wire rack earlier than serving.
